Women doctors have made amazing strides in the field, where only half a century earlier, it was almost exclusively dominated by men. Yet while the doors have opened to women doctors in most aspects, there is one notable exception: motherhood.
My favorite story of women breaking into this, male-dominated field is the one of Agnodice, who disguised herself as a man so that she could study medicine in ancient Greece. Many girls want to grow up to be both well-regarded doctors and wonderful mothers, but it seems that for the most part, they can’t have their cake and eat it too. Men can enter whatever field they want with little consequence, women must make sacrifices. I acknowledge that this seems to be changing, but the pace is still painfully slow.
To paraphrase a professor of mine, the world is still cruel to women. They are encouraged to pursue their career and focus on it with razor sharp focus, while their biological clocks tick away, independent of any aspirations they may develop down the road to start a family. Once the residency and fellowship parade is over (as the case were for aspiring doctors), and a woman is ready to start a family, it may already be too late. I’m all for women being driven and seizing life by the horns, but sometimes the cost is pretty great.
And then, there is me and those like me, who are from immigrant families who insist upon marriage and having at least the first child before age 30. If I am lucky, I will enter medical school at 24, take four years, and enter whatever specialty I can. Depending on what specialty that is, the years devoted to residencies and fellowships may be as low as 3 or as high as 6-7. People can say “Rebel! Blaze your own trail, do what you need to do to get what you want.” Yet in cultures where filial piety is prized and expected, it is far harder to go against the grain, even when your own wishes may be at stake. How does one reconcile cultural and societal obligations with the rigors of medical school/further training?
From what I can gather (and please correct me if I’m wrong) but several residencies tend to not look kindly on women who are pregnant or who have very young children. Each specialty requires a certain number of years of training. It makes sense, of course, that the more high-stakes residencies (for example neurosurgery) would probably require more time to train physicians in that field. Obviously I’d want my neurosurgeon (heaven forbid that I need one) to have had rigorous training. Yet there are 194 certified women neurosurgeons, out of something like 3000 neurosurgeons in total in the U.S. The difference between those numbers is alarming. It’s enough to discourage most women from even entertaining the idea of going down that road, but I’m not like most women. Many women seem to end up vying for the more “family-friendly” positions like family physician or pediatrician, or at least ones that finish up training quickly.
I am not one of those people, I’m aiming for one of the neuro residencies (neurosurgery if I can help it).* I love the complicated nature of the field, and yes, I love the potentially maddening level of stress that’s involved. It’s a field I greatly respect and I want to be a part of, but could potentially be turned away because I want to devote the same kind of attention to my family.
I went to a seminar being conducted at SUNY Downstate, giving advice for medical students as to when they should get married and start families. Literally, the window of opportunity was a few months at best for both, where the birth of a child could potentially set students back a year. Clearly under these restrictions, days-long, traditional Indian weddings are out the window. If I were to get pregnant year 3 or 4, that could be potentially problematic, whereas the first two years were a bit better (but by no means ideal). Heaven forbid you wanted to take care of your child until they were at least more communicative or mobile, and when their fear of strangers was under control (Piagetian child psychology sets this at around 2 years of age). Then perhaps the babysitter could be introduced, if you don’t mind having a babysitter or nanny (I do mind). Children are for many people, a vital part of their lives, and they have the right to get as much time early on with their parents as they can. Yet as far as I can tell, the policy seems to be to leave everything to after you start practicing. That’s great for some people, but others are (still) bound by age-old traditions and (sometimes antiquated though biologically sound) cultural expectations regarding marriage and childbirth.
Hopefully, the domination by men that still seems to be inherent will continue to be addressed, and will encourage more women to live their lives a bit more easily while pursuing their dreams. If any women doctors come across this, I’d love to hear your perspective, given that mine is pretty limited.
*This is all contingent on my getting into medical school. I’m not going to crow about medicine without putting in that little point in there, I’m not in medical school yet. Hopefully I will be soon, gotta take it one step at a time. Even contemplating residencies is a long way off, but it can’t hurt to start contemplating a little now!



20 comments
Comments feed for this article
April 12, 2009 at 8:54 am
trolleywood
This is quite interesting. Frankly I think if a woman wants to go into medicine, then she should ideally wait until after her training to start a family. Otherwise, you can’t really do both well. I’m a proponent of not sending your kids to a nanny or baby sitter, at least for the first few years before they start school, and being at home yourself to take care of them. Now, this doesn’t mean the mother has to always be there, fathers can also be at home part time while the mother works. There are so many arrangements that can be made.
Also, I don’t mean to come off as sexist when I imply that a child or marriage will only put a kink in the mother’s medical education (or any education or career advancement). But the mother does have to carry a child for 9 months, and goes through significantly more hormonal changes, etc that are associated with the pregnancy. I guess people in the medical profession probably foresee these issues and that is why they are encouraging starting a family after med school and residency. I agree with that.
April 12, 2009 at 1:32 pm
sospokesaroj
Nonetheless, despite the fact that doctors are probably more aware of the hormonal burden of pregnancy, why push it to a time when getting pregnant is much harder? Age reduces the chance of getting pregnant and maintaining a pregnancy to term.
April 12, 2009 at 9:10 am
trolleywood
Also, Saroj, please get married soon (disregard what I said earlier). I really want to go to a wedding.
April 12, 2009 at 1:32 pm
sospokesaroj
LOL find me a good guy, and I’ll see what I can do. :p
April 22, 2009 at 4:58 am
chrissy
When are you applying to medical school? are you applying for the fall?
By the way, if you are uncomfortable with a “nanny or babysitter” taking care or your children, you’d still have the option of leaving it with it’s grandparents for the day so the parents wouldnt have to take off from school/work.
Do people ever take a “year off” from med-school? Or is that kind on unheard of? I guess it would be hard considering all the loans which you can’t pay off till you start really making money.
I’ve noticed, not just in medicine but in most fields — business, law, finance — the most successful women have a tendency not to have kids. Which is a sad thing, and I’m sure doesnt hold true for men.
What are the rules for Indian culture? You are supposed to get married and have a kid before 30? What if you got married before 30 but still waited to have a kid till after? If you find another med-student to marry, they’d probably understand and maybe want a similar situation.
My godmother was 40 when she had her first child, and now is pregnant again about 2 yrs later. Everyone in my family was suprised that she decided to have kids so late, but sometimes people just need to go at their own pace through life… and it will still work out for them, even if it doesn’t make everyone else around them happy.
April 23, 2009 at 11:07 pm
sospokesaroj
Lord knows my parents are just itching for that responsibility…anxiously awaiting the grandkids so they get babysitting duty.
Yup I’m applying this summer for 2010. I guess the rule of thumb for Indian girls tends to be to get married before 30, and ideally have your first child before 30. Haha it would be convenient if I ended up marrying another med student, but from what I’ve heard, most med students at that point are in serious relationships by that time. Sigh.