I have no health insurance. I have to worry about getting a cold, getting a flu, getting food poisoning, or some other unfortunate ill. Heaven forbid I do, I have no way to go and see a doctor for any sort of treatment. In the back of my head, I worry every time I step out off the curb into the crosswalk, worry that some crazed taxi driver will gun his engine and inadvertently take me out. In that case, I hope I go quickly and painlessly, and not have to end up in a hospital and drive my family into bankruptcy. That is my prayer, in the supposed land of freedom and opportunity.
I, along with many of my peers, went to college and are pursuing further grad work. I, along with many of my peers, are in debt up to our eyeballs. Cornell Arts and Sciences costs something in the order of $40K, though I was in Cornell’s College of Human Ecology, a measly $20K as a New York State resident. Meanwhile, I just Googled the tuition cost to attend the University of Cambridge in England and here is what it said:
“In 2009, the University of Cambridge will charge tuition fees of £3,145 (plus a small inflationary rise to be determined by the DIUS) per year for all courses, as outlined in our Access Agreement, which has been approved by the Office for Fair Access (OFFA).” (http://www.cam.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/finance/tuition.html). That’s $4654. Per year. At one of the world’s premier universities. In order to succeed in the land of freedom and opportunity [the United States] you must be willing to fork over an arm and a leg, in addition to your firstborn. This is the mantra that the country continues to chant.
So getting back to my story. I have no health insurance, and I’m signing loan after loan to pay my way through school. Theoretically, I have only another…5 more years of school to go before I get a steady paycheck. After that, maybe another thirty years before I pay off my loans. Even if I didn’t take my double-masters detour from medical school, I would still be paying off loans well into my child’s teen years.
I have tried to find a job, but finding a job in itself is a hassle. I finally got one, after 6 to 7 months of searching (not including the tutoring position I currently have). Other friends, though, are still in the job-hunting game, with little to no success. Most, if not all, are from top-tier universities around the country. Even if they’re not, they are certainly smart and capable, yet they are all being denied. Welcome to the United States, the land of freedom and opportunity.
Why have we failed our own people?
Part of the problem is we are still operating in an exclusively capitalistic mindset. Privatize this and that so that the brunt of the cost falls on the individual and the group is spared. Leave it to market forces, because the market will cure all. We have no concern for the group, just the individual, whose health and future is put in the hands of the market. This is the equivalent of leaving them in the hands of a temperamental child, easily swayed, and never entirely stable. Inflation is only driving costs up. While, in the case of healthcare, Medicaid and Medicare do exist and for education, there is state and federal financial aid, they are imperfect solutions.
Medicaid remains a often-abused and neglected system. Millions, if not billions of dollars, are being spent because clinicians are billing the system fraudulently, exploiting loopholes in the system that have yet to be resolved. If they aren’t inappropriately billing the system, they are less likely to treat patients on Medicaid, and those hospitals and clinics that do accept Medicaid are notorious for being sub-par in comparison to their private counterparts. While Medicaid targets those who are often well-below the poverty line, and private insurance takes care of people in the upper brackets, there is still a whole set of people who are neither poor but are neither capable of shelling out money for private insurance that are left without health insurance. There are no resources for these people.
“Give me your poor, your tired, your huddled masses…” unless they’re above this income bracket and below another. In that case, you’re on your own.
Yet even if you can pay for private health insurance, you are probably out of luck if you were to end up with a major medical condition. While routine checkups and most lab tests are covered by most health insurance plans, the more complex procedures are oftentimes not covered. So regardless of your status, in terms of health insurance coverage, there are problems just waiting to happen from which no one can effectively bail you out. Russian Roulette, if you will.
Welcome to the United State, the land of freedom and opportunity.
If someone wants to have enough money, not just to pay off health insurance, but to have a decent quality of life, they need an education. Education, especially in recent years, has become prohibitively expensive. People who would otherwise be capable of getting into an Ivy League are stopped short by the costs, and have to go somewhere else (which may not necessarily be a bad thing, refer to my earlier post). Inflation is driving up university costs at astronomical rates, and greater pressures are being put on colleges to construct new buildings and upgrade what they already have, adding to the cost. Why do we have to be restricted from attending some of the nation’s finest universities by something like cost? We have become a society of debtors, in part due to this phenomenon. Don’t even get me started on the fact that, despite the fact that we pay through our (insert orefice of choice here) for a halfway decent education, we lag behind most of the world, especially in science and mathematics. That’s for another post.
The irony is that I want to be a doctor with a few grad degrees aside from my MD, and currently I neither have health insurance nor a sound way of even paying for one grad degree, let alone medical school.
Welcome to the United States, land of freedom and opportunity.
Dear President-elect Obama: Do you hear the the death moans of a nation once at the pinnacle of greatness, now reduced to a society of forgotten people, languishing in their own physical and financial sickness? You spoke of healthcare for everyone, where even the poorest person can have the same healthcare as a United States Senator. Coming from a distinguished background, you know the pain students go through to get a decent education, just to enjoy some of the benefits that you have. I will bite my tongue and pay my loans off as best as I can, dutifully carry around my bottle of Purrell in an effort to stave off illnesses for the time being, and look both ways before I cross the street (in a very anti-New Yorker fashion) but at some point this needs to stop. I need to stop worrying about how I’m going to pay for my education and I need to stop worrying about whether my next step could land me in a hospital. More importantly, though, my younger brother shouldn’t have to worry about which college he can afford to go to, or how he’ll be able to get healthcare once he’s older. My parents shelled out a lot just to see me enjoy opportunities that in some cases, they had to forgo. Now that the second one is lining up for his turn, I don’t want to see them struggle anymore.
Can you bring meaning back to the phrase “Welcome to the United States, the land of freedom and opportunity,” and not leave it sounding sarcastic and empty? Can you fix it?




8 comments
Comments feed for this article
November 13, 2008 at 4:02 pm
Caroline
Do you really not have insurance? I’m about to loose mine! I ran out of credits at Downstate (I’m only taking two classes next semester and that’s all i need to graduate – but I’m not “full time” according to GHI/United HealthCare). Did you look into Medicaid or MetroPlus Health or Healthy NY? You may not be eligible bc you live on LI, but its worth a try. It just sucks so much bc I picked my doctors with the future in mind – I like my gyn and I picked her bc I’d be ok with her delivering my kid (if and when, if annnnd when lol). Did I mention I’m Irish and need to go to the dentist three times a year? Yeaaa… life really sucks.
November 13, 2008 at 5:33 pm
chrissy
i attached a link to a documentary on people without healthcare that i recently came across
synopsis
What happens if you fall sick and are one of 47 million people in America without health insurance? Critical Condition puts a human face on the nation’s growing health care crisis by capturing the harrowing struggles of four critically ill Americans who discover that being uninsured can cost them their jobs, health, home, savings, and even their lives.
If you aren’t making alot of money in your new job while you’re paying for school, maybe you can apply for low income subsidies like medicaid. i dunno exactly what the requirements are for that, i’m sure there’s other low income healthcare programs also
http://www.medhealthinsurance.com/low-income-insurance.htm
if you declare yourself as an independant from your parents and are in school and not making that much, you may also qualify for low-income housing (and get to live in manhattan yay!) or even food stamps? (yay free food!) to help with costs.
you should try talking with a financial advisor at your school about your options. you should have health insurance!
November 13, 2008 at 5:34 pm
chrissy
btw you should make an announcement about the cornell parade in nyc on saturday on your blog
November 13, 2008 at 5:59 pm
Swami
Well Universal Healthcare could mean higher taxes on other ends…and “Fast Track” – wont mean diddly inside an ER. and I would try and kill off lobbyists of Pharmaceutical Corp and People First country is socialism philosophy – one that capitalism isnt so keen on
November 14, 2008 at 2:44 am
preeta
are you a full-time student in grad school right now? shouldn’t you be covered under their plan?
if you’re not a full-time student or full-time employee right now, you can probably get covered under COBRA, right? i believe i can get COBRA coverage for my semester off.
November 14, 2008 at 1:40 pm
Steven
Saroj! You know I’m totally in the same boat here, minus the fact that I’m not enrolled in grad school. Yet. But yeah, no health insurance and no job sucks. Because, you know, since I’m gay, I’m going to get AIDS and die. No, but really, it’s scary. I miss having annual checkups and stuff. At least I knew I was healthy then. What if I’m dying and I don’t know it?! Haha. I laugh about it, but it’s certainly no laughing matter.
~Steven
November 14, 2008 at 5:04 pm
sospokesaroj
Caroline, I’m looking into Medicaid for myself, but I’ll have to think it through. I gotta see if I can be covered at NYU, or if I can still beg my dad’s insurance company to keep me covered somehow. I dunno.
Steven, it certainly is no laughing matter. Ah if only our country gave a crap about people instead of money. Seriously, if I ever make it to becoming a physician, I hope I can work it out so that my patients don’t have to have insurance to get treated. Well hopefully by then universal healthcare will be close to a reality, if not already there.
November 26, 2008 at 9:12 am
B
Health care In US is really expensive. I remember I had gone to the dentist and it turned out that I needed to have a root canal done and boy was I blown away when I was given the estimate. It was way over the top inspite of having insurance. Back home in India I am so much in awe of our doctors especially the dentists as they do a lot of major work at a pittance. I am glad I could do the RCT back home so cheaply.